Shopping for boots online is tricky, especially when sizing is involved. Truman Boots, particularly on the P-79 last, are no exception. After collecting over a dozen pairs of Truman boots and navigating the sizing maze myself, I’ve learned a thing or two that might help make the process smoother for you.
Let’s break it all down, step by step, so you can get the right fit without the headaches.
Why Sizing Is So Complicated
Getting the perfect fit in boots isn’t just about a single number. There’s a lot to consider: the shape of the last, the thickness of the leather, how your foot changes throughout the day—even things like weight loss or gain can impact the sizing.
On top of that, no two brands fit exactly the same. Even within the same brand, there are slight differences between individual boots because they’re handmade. For Truman boots specifically, their advice leans toward sizing up by half when switching from certain brands. But it’s not always that simple.
First Rule: Consult the Experts
Before diving into comparisons, always check with Truman directly. They design their boots, so they’re familiar with the materials, lasts, and general fit. Their sizing advice works for the vast majority of people. Start there.
That said, personal preference matters too. Some people love a snug fit, while others prefer more room for comfort. Both are valid—figure out what works for you.
Sizing Basics for Truman Boots
Here’s a quick summary of the sizing approach I’ve found most consistent over the years:
- Structured vs. Unstructured Toes: Structured toes on Truman boots add more volume inside the boot, making them feel roomier. Unstructured toes are sleeker and can feel snugger.
- Typical Truman Sizing: I wear an 8.5D in most brands and find that works in Truman too. However, on boots with an unstructured toe or a dressier style, I sometimes size up to a 9D for a better fit.
Foot Swelling and Daily Changes
Your feet don’t stay the same size all day. In the morning, they’re at their smallest, but by the afternoon, they can swell quite a bit, especially after being on your feet. Keep this in mind when deciding how much room you want in your boots.
Personally, I go for a generous fit because I hate the feeling of anything cutting off circulation. Tight boots aren’t just uncomfortable—they’re bad for your feet.
Comparing Truman Boots to Other Brands
If you’re coming from other popular boot brands, sizing comparisons can help, but they’re not foolproof. Different lasts fit differently, and leather thickness can change how a boot feels. Here’s how Truman’s P-79 last stacks up against a few common brands I’ve tried:
Alden
- Truman advises sizing up half a size from your Alden TrueBalance size.
- Example: If you wear an 8.5D in Alden, a 9D in Truman often fits well.
- Alden’s TrueBalance last has a wider toe box, while Truman is more generous in the heel.
Viberg
- Truman recommends going up half a size from your Viberg.
- Example: 8.5D in Viberg translates to a 9D in Truman.
- Viberg's 2030 last has a more pointed almond toe, whereas Truman’s P-79 last has a rounder, more classic toe shape.
Grant Stone
- No official size guide from Truman for Grant Stone, but I’d suggest the same size or half a size up.
- Example: My 8.5D in Grant Stone feels comparable to a 9D in Truman, depending on the leather type.
Red Wing
- For Truman boots, sizing up half a size from your Red Wings works in many cases, though this depends on the specific Red Wing last.
- Example: 8.5D in Red Wing Iron Rangers often translates into a 9D in Truman P-79.
- Note: The Red Wing Moc Toe and Iron Rangers don’t always compare cleanly to Truman due to their raised toe design.
The Impact of Leather Thickness
One thing people overlook is how the leather itself can affect the fit. Truman often uses thicker hides, which take up more space inside the boot. For example:
- Thicker Leather (e.g., Wax Flesh, Chrome Excel): These materials create a tighter fit.
- Thinner Leather (e.g., Shell Cordovan): Boots with thinner leather often feel roomier.
For boots made with thicker materials, I’ve noticed that even my usual size can sometimes feel snugger. That’s something to keep in mind if you prefer looser fits or plan to wear thicker socks.
My Personal Experience
Over the years, I’ve gone back and forth between 8.5D and 9D in Truman boots, depending on the style and material.
Here’s what I’ve found works for me based on specific models:
- Tuscanello Horse Rump (9D): Slightly bigger fit due to the unstructured toe.
- Java Wax Flesh (8.5D): Structured toe feels perfect at true size.
- Coach Rambler (8.5D): Fits like a glove—structured but not too snug.
I also learned to always compare boots by holding the left boot against another left boot (or right vs. right). Handmade boots have minor size variations from boot to boot, so mixing left and right can throw off your comparison.
What About Weight Loss?
Fun fact: Losing or gaining weight can change your foot size. When I recently dropped a bit of weight, my boots started fitting looser. It’s not just fat—it’s a combination of reduced fluid, skin, and even capillary shrinkage. So, if you’ve been training or dropping pounds, your usual size may feel different.
Practical Tips for Sizing Truman Boots
Here’s a quick checklist to keep it simple:
- Ask Truman First: Their customer service is excellent and can suggest the best size for you.
- Know Your Branded Size: Compare from brands you already own, but don’t assume the same size will work perfectly across brands.
- Consider Structured vs. Unstructured Toes: Structured toes fit roomier, while unstructured versions feel snugger.
- Account for Leather Thickness: Thick hides leave less room inside the boot. Thin leather fits looser.
- Try on with Socks: Use the same type of socks you’ll wear regularly to check the fit.
Final Thoughts
Getting the right size in Truman boots, or any boots, isn’t an exact science. There are many variables, and no two people’s feet are exactly the same. That’s a good thing, though—it means you’ve got options to make your boots fit how you like them.
If you’re still unsure, don’t stress. Start by consulting Truman’s team, and don’t be afraid to experiment. Once you nail down your fit, you’ll find the process much easier the next time.
See YouTube video https://youtu.be/T3TYFeJ1LG8?si=6nfNuB1tA8cO91FK
Shop Truman Boots: https://www.trumanboot.com/?ref=rromfnmy For 10% off use promo code: DALE