Hey everyone! Today, we’re diving into a topic that has sparked quite a bit of discussion online: the Alden 403 versus the Alden 405 boots. I’ve owned both for about a year now, and I wanted to share my thoughts and experiences to help you decide which one, if not both, might be right for you.
First off, let me just say that both boots are fantastic. If you’re a fan of Alden and the Indy boot style, I highly recommend getting both because they each have their unique strengths. Personally, I think it’s a tie, but let’s break down the differences.
Leather Differences
One of the most noticeable differences between the two boots is the type of leather used. The 403 features Chromexcel leather, while the 405 is made from calfskin.
- Chromexcel Leather (403): After a year of wear, this leather shows its age more prominently. You can see the creases and scuffs clearly, and it has a darker appearance. However, it’s also quite resilient. I’ve been using a Venetian leather balm, which works wonders to restore it to its original state.
- Calfskin Leather (405): In contrast, the calfskin on the 405 looks almost brand new after the same period. It’s fascinating how little wear is visible, making it a great choice if you prefer a boot that maintains its pristine look.
Breaking In
Another key difference lies in how each boot breaks in. Both are size 8.5D, but the Chromexcel leather stretches more significantly compared to the calfskin. After breaking them in, the eyelet spacing on the 403 has increased, while the 405 remains snug and supportive.
Walking around in the 405 gives a feeling of support, whereas the 403 allows for a bit more wiggle room for your toes. This doesn’t mean one is better than the other; it just depends on your preference for fit and support.
Common Confusion
There’s a bit of confusion in the market regarding these two models, especially since J.Crew lists the 403 as the Alden Indy 405. Just to clarify, the version sold by J.Crew is actually the 403 in brown Chromexcel leather, not the 405.
Which One to Choose?
If you’re drawn to the Indy boots because of Indiana Jones, it’s worth noting that he wore the 405. However, the version he wore back in the day was a different style altogether. Alden has evolved their designs over the years.
For those looking for a more screen-accurate version, Leather Soul Hawaii now offers what they call the Vintage Indies, which resemble the boots worn by Harrison Ford, though they come with a Commando sole.
Color Preference
When it comes to color, I personally prefer the Chromexcel of the 403. It’s much more versatile and pairs well with all types of jeans, both dark and light. The 405, while beautiful, doesn’t quite match darker jeans as well.
Interestingly, I’ve seen some friends wear the 403 with suits, which I wouldn’t recommend for the 405 due to its more casual aesthetic.
Final Thoughts
Ultimately, both Alden boots have their merits. If you’re after a boot that ages beautifully and can handle a bit of wear, the 403 is your go-to. On the other hand, if you want something that looks fresh even after a year, the 405 is the way to go. I think both are excellent choices, and if you can, owning both will give you the best of both worlds!
Thanks for following along, and I hope this comparison provides some clarity as you navigate your boot choices!
See YouTube video https://youtu.be/qOPeU3KRxps?si=FbkNbeRz99Cu8YiI